When your laptop starts sounding like a jet engine under the desk or feels too hot to touch during a Zoom call, it’s time to seriously consider a cooling solution. Two popular options have caught the attention of laptop users: the Targus 17 Inch Dual Fan Lap Chill Mat and the Laptop Cooling Pad with 9 Quiet Fans. Both promise to keep your device cool, but they take very different approaches. Whether you’re a student cramming for exams, a remote worker juggling spreadsheets, or a gamer pushing your machine to its limits, choosing the right cooling pad can make a real difference in comfort, performance, and longevity of your laptop.
This comparison dives deep into these two top contenders to help you decide which one fits your lifestyle best. We’ll break down their features, performance, build quality, and real-world usability—based on actual customer experiences—so you don’t have to guess. By the end, you’ll know exactly which cooling pad delivers better value, quieter operation, and whether it’s built for portability or serious power cooling.
In-Depth Look: Targus 17 Inch Dual
Product Info Card:
ASIN: B002NU5O9C
Short Name: Targus 17 Inch Dual
Full Title: Targus 17 Inch Dual Fan Lap Chill Mat – Soft Neoprene Laptop Cooling Pad for Hea
Price: $29.99 – $39.99
Average Rating: 4.5/5 (based on 2,800+ reviews)
Best Use Case: Laptop users who work on their lap or need portability
The Targus 17 Inch Dual Fan Lap Chill Mat is a no-nonsense solution designed for comfort and quiet cooling. Unlike bulky gaming stands, this pad is built with a soft neoprene base that cradles your lap, making long work sessions far more pleasant. Its ergonomic 3-degree tilt helps reduce wrist strain, and the open mesh top ensures steady airflow without blocking your laptop’s vents. What really sets it apart is its lightweight design—perfect for students, travelers, or anyone who needs a cooling solution that doesn’t weigh them down.
Powered by two whisper-quiet fans connected via USB, the Targus 17 Inch Dual doesn’t just cool—it does so without blasting noise into your workspace. The included USB hub means you can plug in peripherals without hunting for an outlet. Whether you’re editing videos, writing reports, or streaming movies, this pad keeps things chill without the distraction of bright lights or loud hums.
One of the standout features is how well it handles weight distribution. Many users report that bulky laptops that used to make their legs ache now sit comfortably on their laps, thanks to the cushioned neoprene surface. And unlike some plastic cooling pads that feel cheap or slide around, the rubber stops on the front keep your laptop firmly in place—even during light typing or scrolling.
While it lacks adjustable height and flashy RGB lights, the Targus 17 Inch Dual makes up for it with reliability and simplicity. It’s not the most powerful cooler out there, but for everyday use, it strikes a great balance between performance and comfort.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Ultra-quiet operation—perfect for offices or shared spaces
- Soft neoprene base enhances lap comfort
- Lightweight and portable
- Includes USB hub for extra connectivity
- Sturdy build with anti-slip rubber stops
Cons:
- Only 2 fans—less aggressive cooling than high-end models
- Fixed tilt angle (though ergonomic)
- No lighting or advanced controls
What Customers Are Saying
“I’ve been using it for a few days so far and it works well and is very quiet. Also the guy who said it wouldn’t fit a 17″ laptop was wrong, it fits mine quite comfortably. It’s lightweight and comfortable to use on my lap, and I’ve been surprised at how well it distributes the weight of my bulky laptop so it doesn’t make my legs hurt, unlike some regular lap desks.” – Verified Purchase
“The Targus chill mat is a superior product to my first chill pad. The operation of the fans is quiet, and they run consistently without issue. I have not had an issue with my laptop feeling hot since I started using the chill pad.” – Verified Purchase
“This chill mat worked great when playing games on my HP Omen 16. The fans weren’t as loud and it definitely didn’t overheat on my desk. I wish I was able to adjust it because I need to use another keyboard while gaming and my desk is pretty small as it is.” – Verified Purchase
Best For
The Targus 17 Inch Dual is ideal for professionals, students, and remote workers who value comfort and portability. If you frequently work from your couch, coffee shop, or plane seat, this pad offers reliable cooling without the bulk. It’s also a great choice if you want something quiet for late-night study sessions or video calls.
In-Depth Look: Laptop Cooling Pad
Product Info Card:
ASIN: B0DR87WW4P
Short Name: Laptop Cooling Pad
Full Title: Laptop Cooling Pad, Gaming Laptop Cooler with 9 Quiet Fans, Laptop Cooling Stand
Price: $39.99 – $59.99
Average Rating: 4.4/5 (based on 1,200+ reviews)
Best Use Case: Gamers and power users needing maximum airflow
When performance is non-negotiable, the Laptop Cooling Pad steps up with nine high-speed fans and five adjustable height settings. Designed for gaming laptops and heavy workloads, this stand prioritizes airflow over portability. Its mesh construction allows massive air intake, pushing cool air directly onto your laptop’s underside—perfect for preventing thermal throttling during long gaming marathons or video renders.
What makes this pad stand out is its customization. You get two gear switches to control fan speeds independently, letting you balance cooling with noise levels. Need maximum airflow? Turn both up. Prefer a quieter setup for streaming? Dial it back. The RGB lighting adds a cool aesthetic, and the hidden phone holder keeps your setup tidy. Dual USB-A ports mean you can connect extra devices without sacrificing power.
Build-wise, it’s sturdy and designed for desk use. The anti-slip baffle prevents sliding, and the foldable design saves space when not in use. While it’s heavier than the Targus model, that weight comes from reinforced plastic and a solid frame that won’t wobble during intense usage.
The trade-off? It’s not ideal for lap use due to its size and lack of soft padding. But if you’re serious about cooling your high-performance laptop, this pad delivers serious airflow without breaking a sweat.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- 9 powerful fans for aggressive cooling
- Five adjustable height levels for ergonomic positioning
- RGB lighting with multiple modes
- Dual USB ports for device charging
- Anti-slip design and phone holder
Cons:
- Heavier and less portable
- No lap-friendly padding
- RGB may be distracting in quiet environments
- Slightly higher price point
What Customers Are Saying
“Works well and has lasted years now. Keeps my very loud gaming laptop cool while playing games.” – Verified Purchase
“Laptops have a little fan inside the keyboard platform, but sometimes they still overheat. When they overheat, the screen starts doing crazy things. Sometimes the system just shuts down. For that reason, we always use this platform—it gives the laptop a stable surface, allows for air-circulation underneath, and the blue lights assure you that the fans are on.” – Verified Purchase
“As the proud owner of a new gaming laptop, I was advised to get a cooling pad because,… heat. So I did. PROS: Big. Just the right size for my 16” laptop. Lots o’ fans. I mean nine fans in the frame. Multiple tilt levels. This is important to me since I need the laptop keyboard elevated to see the keys properly.” – Verified Purchase
Best For
The Laptop Cooling Pad is best suited for gamers, video editors, and power users with high-performance laptops. If your machine runs hot under load and you need consistent, aggressive cooling, this pad delivers. Its adjustable heights also make it great for users who suffer from neck or back strain and need better posture support during long sessions.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Cooling Performance
When it comes to raw cooling power, the Laptop Cooling Pad has a clear edge. With nine fans compared to the Targus 17 Inch Dual’s two, it creates a much stronger airflow—ideal for gaming laptops or systems running intensive software. Users with overheating issues report fewer thermal throttling incidents with the nine-fan model. However, for everyday tasks like web browsing, document editing, or streaming, the Targus pad is more than sufficient and far quieter.
Portability & Comfort
This is where the Targus 17 Inch Dual shines. Its lightweight design and neoprene base make it perfect for lap use, travel, or working from unconventional spaces. The Laptop Cooling Pad, while sturdy, is bulkier and better suited for fixed desk environments. If you carry your laptop everywhere, the Targus is the obvious choice.
Noise Level
Both models are designed to be quiet, but they cater to different needs. The Targus runs at near-silent levels—ideal for offices or shared living spaces. The Laptop Cooling Pad, while rated at 28dB, can get louder at max speed, especially with all nine fans spinning. If silence is a priority, the Targus wins hands down.
Customization & Features
The Laptop Cooling Pad offers more advanced features: adjustable heights, RGB lighting, dual USB ports, and independent fan controls. These extras appeal to gamers and tech enthusiasts who enjoy tweaking their setup. The Targus, by contrast, focuses on simplicity—no distractions, just reliable cooling.
Build Quality & Durability
Both are well-built, but for different use cases. The Targus uses soft neoprene and lightweight materials, which may wear faster with heavy daily use. The Laptop Cooling Pad uses reinforced plastic and a solid frame, making it more durable for long-term desk use. If you drop your laptop occasionally or use it in rugged conditions, the Laptop Cooling Pad’s sturdier build is a plus.
Value for Money
The Targus 17 Inch Dual offers excellent value for basic cooling needs—its price point makes it accessible for most users. The Laptop Cooling Pad costs more, but justifies the price with superior cooling, ergonomics, and features. If your budget is tight or you don’t need extreme cooling, the Targus is the smarter buy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which cooling pad is better for gaming?
A: The Laptop Cooling Pad is better for gaming due to its nine fans and aggressive airflow. It prevents overheating during long sessions, which is crucial for maintaining performance in demanding games. Check Price on Amazon
Q: Can I use the Targus 17 Inch Dual on a desk?
A: Yes, the Targus 17 Inch Dual can be used on a desk, but its primary design is for lap use. Its compact size and soft base make it versatile, though it lacks height adjustability. Check Price on Amazon
Q: Do I need RGB lighting in a laptop cooling pad?
A: Not really. RGB adds style but isn’t necessary for performance. The Targus 17 Inch Dual offers a clean, distraction-free experience, which many users prefer. Check Price on Amazon
Q: Which one is quieter?
A: The Targus 17 Inch Dual is quieter overall, with fans that run almost silently. The Laptop Cooling Pad can get louder at higher speeds, though it’s still within acceptable limits for most users.
Q: Can I charge my phone using these cooling pads?
A: Yes! Both models include USB ports. The Targus has a built-in USB hub, while the Laptop Cooling Pad offers dual USB-A ports—perfect for charging phones, mice, or keyboards.
Q: Are these compatible with 17-inch laptops?
A: Yes, both are designed to fit laptops up to 17 inches. The Targus model is specifically labeled for 17-inch devices, while the Laptop Cooling Pad accommodates up to 17 inches with its foldable baffle.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
After comparing every aspect—cooling power, portability, noise, features, and user experience—the best choice depends entirely on how you use your laptop.
If you’re a student, remote worker, or someone who values comfort and quiet, the Targus 17 Inch Dual is your winner. It’s lightweight, lap-friendly, and delivers reliable cooling without the noise or bulk. Its neoprene base and ergonomic tilt make long hours of work or study a breeze.
On the other hand, if you’re a gamer, video editor, or run power-hungry applications, the Laptop Cooling Pad is the better investment. Nine fans, adjustable heights, and RGB lighting give it an edge in performance and customization. It’s built for serious users who need maximum airflow and don’t mind a slightly heavier, desk-bound setup.
Ultimately, both are excellent choices—just for different lifestyles. For everyday use and portability, go with the Targus. For gaming and heavy workloads, choose the Laptop Cooling Pad.
For more laptop accessories and guides, check out our Best Laptop for Xtool or explore our Gaming Laptop vs Normal Laptop comparison to find the perfect machine to pair with your new cooling pad.

